王天彩, 陈晨, 马朦朦, 杨茜, 李耘, 钱永忠. 五种农药及其二元、三元组合对人肝癌HepG2细胞的联合毒性[J]. 农药学学报, 2021, 23(3): 499-508. DOI: 10.16801/j.issn.1008-7303.2021.0021
    引用本文: 王天彩, 陈晨, 马朦朦, 杨茜, 李耘, 钱永忠. 五种农药及其二元、三元组合对人肝癌HepG2细胞的联合毒性[J]. 农药学学报, 2021, 23(3): 499-508. DOI: 10.16801/j.issn.1008-7303.2021.0021
    WANG Tiancai, CHEN Chen, MA Mengmeng, YANG Xi, LI Yun, QIAN Yongzhong. Combined toxicity of five pesticides and their binary and ternary mixtures on HepG2 cells[J]. Chinese Journal of Pesticide Science, 2021, 23(3): 499-508. DOI: 10.16801/j.issn.1008-7303.2021.0021
    Citation: WANG Tiancai, CHEN Chen, MA Mengmeng, YANG Xi, LI Yun, QIAN Yongzhong. Combined toxicity of five pesticides and their binary and ternary mixtures on HepG2 cells[J]. Chinese Journal of Pesticide Science, 2021, 23(3): 499-508. DOI: 10.16801/j.issn.1008-7303.2021.0021

    五种农药及其二元、三元组合对人肝癌HepG2细胞的联合毒性

    Combined toxicity of five pesticides and their binary and ternary mixtures on HepG2 cells

    • 摘要: 为研究农产品中农药混合污染的联合毒性,选取生菜中应用广泛、广谱性强的5种农药(苯醚甲环唑、氯氰菊酯、烯酰吗啉、氯氟氰菊酯和啶虫脒)及其高频检出的二元、三元农药组合为研究对象,采用CCK-8 (Cell Counting Assay Kit-8) 法探究农药单剂及混合物对人肝癌HepG2细胞增殖的抑制毒性,基于单个农药剂量效应曲线按照等效应的联合毒性测定方法,应用浓度相加、独立作用和联合指数3个预测模型推导联合效应,并通过高内涵筛选系统分析农药混合物对人肝癌HepG2细胞凋亡的诱导作用。结果表明:不同农药对HepG2细胞增殖抑制的影响存在较大差异,但均具有明显的剂量-效应关系,其中苯醚甲环唑具有最强的细胞增殖抑制毒性,细胞活力的半数抑制浓度 (EC50) 为24.72 μmol/L;其余农药毒性顺序为烯酰吗啉 > 氯氟氰菊酯 > 啶虫脒 > 氯氰菊酯。通过联合指数判定农药混合物的联合毒性效应的结果表明:所有二元组合均随农药浓度增大表现出细胞增殖抑制效应增强,联合效应由拮抗转为协同;三元组合烯酰吗啉 + 苯醚甲环唑 + 氯氰菊酯、烯酰吗啉 + 氯氰菊酯 + 啶虫脒的细胞增殖抑制效应分别为60%和18%时,联合效应由协同转为拮抗。同时,利用剂量减少指数量化农药混合物之间的协同效应研究表明,在上述两个三元组合的协同效应中,氯氰菊酯发挥较大作用。在凋亡毒性测定中,各农药单独处理组均会造成HepG2细胞凋亡率的显著提高,且呈剂量依赖性;三元组合烯酰吗啉 + 氯氰菊酯 + 啶虫脒在20.02~80.10 μmol/L浓度范围内可诱导细胞凋亡水平显著提升。本研究明确了农药单剂和混合物对HepG2细胞增殖和凋亡毒性具有明显的剂量依赖效应,可为混合农药毒性评价以及风险监测提供科学依据。联合指数模型可以定量地描述农药混合物在不同组分和浓度下的相互作用,对比浓度相加和独立作用模型,可较准确地预测混合物的联合毒性,是一种有效的生态毒理学风险评估工具。

       

      Abstract: To study the combined toxicity of pesticides mixtures in agricultural products, five pesticides with wide application and broad spectrum, including difenoconazole, cypermethrin, dimethomorph, cyhalothrin, acetamiprid, and relevant binary and ternary combinations with high exposure levels in lettuce were selected. Cell Counting Assay Kit-8 method was used to determine the proliferation inhibition toxicity of single pesticide and mixtures on HepG2 hepatocytes. The combined effects were assessed by three prediction models, concentration addition, independent action and combination index, based on the concentration-response curve of individual pesticides. Then the induction effects of two ternary combinations on cell apoptosis were analyzed by High Content Screening. The results showed that the effects of different pesticide combinations on the cell growth inhibitory rate of HepG2 cells were different, all of which had obvious concentration-response relationship. Among them, difenoconazole had a strong inhibition of proliferation toxicity, and the median effective concentration was 24.72 μmol/L. The order of toxicity for the other individual pesticides was ranked as dimethomorph > cyhalothrin > acetamiprid > cypermethrin. The combined toxicity of the pesticide mixtures was determined by the combination index. The results showed that with the increase of pesticide concentrations, the combined effects of all binary combinations changed from antagonism to synergy. While in ternary mixtures, including dimethomorph + difenoconazole + cypermethrin and dimethomorph + cypermethrin + acetamiprid, the combined effects changed from synergy to antagonism when the growth inhibition effect were 60% and 18%, respectively. In addition, the dose reduction index was used to quantify the synergistic effect between pesticide mixtures, indicating that cypermethrin played a greater role in the synergistic effect of the above two ternary combinations. In the measurement of apoptosis toxicity, the apoptotic rate of HepG2 cells significantly increased in the groups treated by individual pesticides in a concentration-dependent manner. The apoptotic rate induced by the ternary combination of dimethomorph + cypermethrin + acetamiprid was significantly increased in concentration between of 20.02-80.10 μmol/L. This work confirmed that the toxicities of proliferation inhibition and apoptosis induction of different pesticides mixtures on HepG2 cells both showed obvious concentration-response relationship, which could provide a scientific basis for toxicity evaluation and risk monitoring of pesticides mixtures. The combination index model as an effective ecotoxicological risk assessment tool can quantitatively describe the interactions of pesticide mixtures under different components and concentrations, which can predict the combined toxicity of pesticide mixtures more accurately compared with the concentration addition model and the independent action model.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回